Skip to main content

Skemp Article

Overall I really liked this article, and found a lot in it that resonated with my own experience learning mathematics. In high school I had an incredible math teacher that definitely subscribed the the "relational understanding" view of mathematics. However, in grade 12 AP calculus he was gone for a semester and our replacement teacher taught in a much more "instrumental understanding" way. I struggled more in that semester than ever before in math, much like the anecdote in the article about the seven-year-old who had extreme difficulty with an "instrumental understanding" approach to mathematics.

As I was reading the article, several pieces stood out to me. I really enjoyed the metaphor of faux amis and the idea that there are not just two different approaches to math, but in fact two different mathematics. While I'm not sure I agree completely with Skemp on this, I think it's a valuable way to think about the two different ways that math is taught, and how the "instrumental understanding" approach fosters a completely different attitude in students towards mathematics than the "relational understanding approach". I was also struck by the parable about teaching music as a purely written subject. I thought this metaphor perfectly captured how and why teaching math for "instrumental understanding" both makes it more difficult in the long run, and robs students of the passion they might feel for the subject. Another part of the article that stood out to me was the piece about walking through a town in order to create a mind map, or simply to get from point A to point B. I think this was possibly the strongest argument in the article for teaching mathematics with a "relational understanding approach". In my experience tutoring mathematics, I have seen students get stuck so many times because they made one mistake and could not get back on track with the steps they had memorized to solve the problem. Having a relational understanding of mathematics is much more versatile, and allows you not only to make mistakes, but to learn from those mistakes and recover.

I fully agree with Skemp on this issue. While I understand that sometimes it may be hard to find time or room in the curriculum to teach every concept for relational understanding, I think the benefits outweigh the challenges in every sense. While instrumental understanding may be faster and easier to teach in the beginning, the gaps in "relational understanding" will pile up over time and it will become difficult to teach for any kind of understanding.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mirco Teaching Lesson Plan

Here is the lesson plan for my micro-teaching on making an origami tulip! Subject: Origami Tulip Class: EDCP 342A Date: October 18, 2017 Duration: 10 min Class Profile Table of 6 students Objectives The objective of this lesson is to teach students how to create their own origami tulip from a square piece of paper. If there is extra time, students will also have the opportunity to make a stem for their tulip. Materials & Equipment Needed Origami paper - 2 pieces for every student (one for the tulip, and one for either a stem or an extra piece if they want to start again. Lesson Stages Learning Activities Time 1 Hook & Introduction The teacher will present show the students an example of the flower the students will be folding, and go over a bit of information about the history of origami: Origami is the Japanese art of paper folding, coming from the Japanese word “Ori” (folding) and “Kami” (paper). There are lots of differ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Micro Teaching Feedback

 Thanks to Peter, Jing, Niloo and Brianna for their feedback on my microteaching! If I were to do this activity again either I would need more time, or I would need to make adjustments. To make it shorter to fit in the 10 minutes I could take out the background information on origami, or start with paper that already had the first four basic folds done. I think people really enjoyed the origami though, and it is a fun skill to learn, so overall I was quite happy with my microteaching. I just need to work on being better at estimating how long things take!
Post a Comment
Read more

Math Art Reflection

I really enjoyed the math art project, especially because I enjoy doing arts and crafts in my spare time. It was interesting exploring the patterns that emerged from assigning colours to the prime factors, and how different patterns emerged when different tilings of the plane were used. It was also interesting researching different prime number sieves - I have some background in that from Number Theory classes I have taken, but I enjoyed looking into them in more depth, and learning about their history. I don't know that I would use this particular project in a math class I was teaching, or that I would assign a "Math Art Project" to my students, unless I found some kind of math art project that was more explicitly connected to whatever I was teaching. But I would definitely have examples of math art around my classroom to pique students interest, and I would love to integrate smaller scale math art projects into individual lessons if they were relevant.
Post a Comment
Read more